Under Dill, there have been 85 students who have played college baseball, including 43 Division I athletes. Some of these include:

- J.J. Muno, UC Santa Barbara
- Jake Hirabayashi, UCLA
- Jordan Myrow, Cal State LA
- Colin Brophy, George Washington University (active)
- Bronson Balholm, Belloit College (active)
- Justin Goossen-Brown, San Diego State
- Logan Pollack, University of Michigan (active)
- Drew Littwin, Chapman (active)
- Noah Taylor, Cal Poly San Luis Obispo (active)
- Isaac Amador, LA Valley College (active)
- Ian White, LA Valley College (active)
- Deandre Carter, LA Valley College (active)
- Michael Whiteside, Point Loma Nazarene University (active)
- Jalen Parks, Cal Lutheran University (active)
- Grant Berman, NYU (active)
- Joshua Perlmutter, Santa Barbara City College
- Michael Wilson, Emory
- Jamie Robertson, Emory